Table 3 Quality assessment
Reference | E1 | E2 | E3 | E4 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Adibe, M. On, et al. (2013) [31] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
2 | Al-Azayzih, A,et al.(2023) [32] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
3 | Alshayban, D, et al.(2020) [33] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
4 | Ananthesh, L,et al.(2024) [34] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
5 | Anirudh, M, et al. (2021) [35] | partial | partial | complete | complete |
6 | Arifin, B, et al.(2019) [36] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
7 | Boye, K. S, et al.(2007) [37] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
8 | Boye, K. S, et al.(2020) [39] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
9 | Boye, K. S, et al.(2023) [40] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
10 | Briggs, A. H, et al.(2017) [41] | partial | complete | partial | complete |
11 | Burström, K,et al.(2001) [43] | complete | complete | partial | complete |
12 | Butt, M,et al.(2018) [44] | complete | complete | partial | complete |
13 | Chang, K,et al.(2010) [45] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
14 | Chen, C. C, et al.(2021) [46] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
15 | Chen, S,et al.(2019) [47] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
16 | Choi, Y. J, et al.(2011) [48] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
17 | Clarke, P,et al.(2002) [49] | complete | complete | partial | complete |
18 | Clarke, P. M, et al.(2009) [50] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
19 | Currie, C. J, et al.(2005) [51] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
20 | Currie, C. J, et al.(2006) [52] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
21 | Cvetanovic, G,et al.(2017) [54] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
22 | Dominguez-Munoz, F. J, et al.(2020) [55] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
23 | Dudzińska, M,et al.(2013) [56] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
24 | Dudzińska, M,et al.(2015) [57] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
25 | Ekwunife, O. I, et al.(2016) [58] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
26 | Elissen, A. M. J, et al.(2017) [59] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
27 | Brown, G.C, et al.(2000) [42] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
28 | Glasziou, P,et al.(2007) [60] | complete | complete | partial | complete |
29 | Gorter, K,et al.(2008) [61] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
30 | Grandy, S,et al.(2008) [62] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
31 | Grandy, S,et al.(2012) [63] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
32 | Grandy, S,et al.(2014) [64] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
33 | Gu, S. Y, et al.(2020) [65] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
34 | Harris, S,et al.(2014) [67] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
35 | Hayes, A,et al.(2016) [68] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
36 | Hoda, F,et al.(2023) [69] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
37 | Ishii, H,et al.(2020) [70] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
38 | Jalkanen, K,et al.(2019) [71] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
39 | Javanbakht, M,et al.(2012) [72] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
40 | Jhita, T,et al.(2014) [73] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
41 | Kamradt, M,et al.(2017) [74] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
42 | Kiadaliri, A. A, et al.(2014) [75] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
43 | Kiadaliri, A. A, et al.(2015) [76] | complete | complete | complete | partial |
44 | Koekkoek, P. S, et al.(2015) [77] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
45 | Kuo, S,et al.(2021) [79] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
46 | Landy, J,et al.(2002) [80] | complete | complete | complete | partial |
47 | Lane, S,et al.(2014) [81] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
48 | Laxy, M,et al.(2021) [82] | complete | complete | partial | complete |
49 | Lee, A. J, et al.(2005) [83] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
50 | Lee, W. J, et al.(2012) [84] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
51 | Lim, L. L, et al.(2023) [85] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
52 | Lui, J. N. M, et al.(2023) [86] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
53 | Maddigan, S. L, et al.(2004) [87] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
54 | Maddigan, S. L, et al.(2006) | complete | complete | complete | complete |
55 | Malanda, U. L, et al.(2011) | partial | partial | partial | complete |
56 | Marrett, E,et al.(2009) [47] | partial | partial | complete | complete |
57 | Matza, L,S, et al.(2024) [91] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
58 | Matza, L. S, et al.(2007) [92] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
59 | Matza, L. S, et al.(2017) [93] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
60 | Matza, Louis S, et al.(2007) [94] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
61 | Mehta, Z,et al.(1999) [95] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
62 | Mihevc, M,et al.(2024) [96] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
63 | Modarresnia, L,et al.(2018) [97] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
64 | Naïditch, N,et al.(2023) [98] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
65 | Nauck, M. A, et al.(2019) [99] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
66 | Nazir, S. R, et al.(2017) [100] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
67 | Neumann, A,et al.(2014) [101] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
68 | Neuwahl, S. J, et al.(2021) [102] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
69 | O’Shea, M. P, et al.(2015) [103] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
70 | Pagkalos, E,et al.(2018) [104] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
71 | Pan, C. W, et al.(2014) [105] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
72 | Pettersson, B,et al.(2010) [106] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
73 | Pham, T. B, et al.(2020) [107] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
74 | Pinchevsky, Y,et al.(2018) [108] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
75 | Pratipanawatr, T,et al.(2019) [109] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
76 | Quah, Joanne H. M, et al.(2011) [110] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
77 | Raisch, D. W, et al.(2012) [111] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
78 | Randeree, H,et al.(2013) [112] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
79 | Reaney, M,et al.(2013) [113] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
80 | Redekop, W. K, et al.(2002) [114] | partial | complete | partial | complete |
81 | Riandini, T,et al.(2018) [115] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
82 | Ridderstråle, M,et al.(2016) [116] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
83 | Rowen, D,et al.(2019) [117] | partial | partial | complete | complete |
84 | Sakamaki, H,et al.(2006) [118] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
85 | Sakthong, P,et al.(2008) [119] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
86 | Shao, H,et al.(2019) [120] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
87 | Sheu, Wayne H. H, et al.(2012) [122] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
88 | Shi, L,et al.(2014) [123] | complete | complete | partial | complete |
89 | Shim, Y. T, et al.(2012) [124] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
90 | Sit, R. W, et al.(2022) [125] | partial | partial | complete | complete |
91 | Smits, K. P. J, et al.(2018) [126] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
92 | Solli, Oddvar, et al.(2010) [127] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
93 | Stevens, G. D, et al.(2015) [128] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
94 | Sullivan, P. W, et al.(2016) [129] | complete | complete | partial | complete |
95 | Sundaram, M,et al.(2009) [130] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
96 | Tan, M. H. P, et al.(2023) [131] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
97 | Tang, Z,et al.(2020) [132] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
98 | Thiel, D. M, et al.(2017) [133] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
99 | Torre, C,et al.(2019) [134] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
100 | Veldwijk, J,et al.(2014) [136] | partial | partial | complete | complete |
101 | Vexiau, P,et al.(2008) [137] | partial | partial | complete | complete |
102 | Wan, E. Y, et al.(2016) [138] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
103 | Wang, P,et al.(2016) [139] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
104 | Wang, Y,et al.(2015) [140] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
105 | Wasem, J,et al.(2013) [141] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
106 | Wexler, D. J, et al.(2006) [142] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
107 | Yang, W,et al.(2014) [143] | complete | partial | complete | complete |
108 | Yu, M,et al.(2017) [144] | partial | complete | complete | complete |
109 | Zare, F,et al.(2020) [145] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
110 | Zhang, P,et al.(2012) [146] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
111 | Zhang, P,et al.(2016) [147] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
112 | Zhang, Y. C, et al.(2020) [148] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
113 | Currie, C. J, et al.(2007) [53] | partial | partial | complete | complete |
114 | Hao, S,et al.(2020) [66] | complete | complete | partial | complete |
115 | Salampessy, B.H, et al.(2015) [120] | partial | partial | complete | complete |
116 | Boye, K. S, et al.(2011) [38] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
117 | Konerding, U, et al.(2017) [78] | complete | complete | complete | complete |
118 | Tung, T.H, et al.(2005) [149] | complete | complete | complete | complete |